Florida Man’s Craigslist Fail: “Looking for Ice or Crack” Lands Him in the Slammer

Jeremiah Pleasant

ByJeremiah Pleasant

April 6, 2025

Ah, Florida. The land of sunshine, palm trees, and… checks notes… people trying to buy drugs on Craigslist like it’s the classifieds section of a 1990s newspaper.

Meet Anthony Mata, a man who clearly missed the memo that Craigslist is for used couches and questionable job offers—not scoring meth. In what can only be described as a bold career move, Mata posted an ad that read: “New to the area, looking for ice or crack.”

Now, most people would assume this was either a typo or a cry for help. But not our guy Anthony. Nope, he was all in. And guess who saw his ad? Not a friendly neighborhood dealer, but an undercover cop who was probably like, “Oh, honey… no.”

The investigator, playing the role of Totally Legit Drug Seller, set up a meet with Mata, who eagerly negotiated an “eight ball” of meth for $80. (Side note: If you’re haggling over meth prices, maybe reevaluate your life choices.)

When Mata showed up to the meet, cash in hand, he got a surprise party—the kind where the guests are deputies and the gift is handcuffs. His buddy, Stephen Hornsby, also got a free ride to jail for being the world’s worst wingman.

Mata now faces charges for purchasing meth and using a two-way communication device unlawfully—because apparently, Craigslist isn’t the preferred marketplace for illegal substances. Who knew?

So, let this be a lesson, folks: If you’re “new to the area” and looking to make friends, maybe try a local meetup group instead of posting a Craigslist ad that reads like a police report waiting to happen.

Mugshots courtesy of the Holmes County Sheriff’s Office—because nothing says “Florida Man” like a booking photo with zero regrets.

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

Get Our Weekly Newsletter!

Your Weekly Fix of Florida's Wildest Tales – Straight to Your Inbox!