Florida Man vs. Gator vs. Cops: The Ultimate Showdown (Spoiler: Nobody Wins)

Liam O'Connor

ByLiam O'Connor

June 5, 2025

Only in Florida does a man survive an alligator attack—just to pick a fight with the cops with garden shears.

It all started when 42-year-old Timothy Schultz decided to spice up his Monday by acting “bizarre” at a Lakeland convenience store. Deputies showed up, but Schultz had already upgraded his morning swim to Extreme Mode by diving into an alligator-infested lake. Because why not?

Witnesses, being the helpful Floridians they are, tossed him a life preserver. Schultz responded like any rational person would—by growling at them. Classic.

Somehow, he made it out of the water (with a fresh gator bite, because Florida) and immediately grabbed a pair of garden shears. Not for pruning bushes, though—oh no. This man had plans.

First, he tried breaking into a truck with a brick (because garden shears weren’t destructive enough). Then, when deputies arrived, Schultz charged at them like a man who had already survived one apex predator and figured, “Why not try my luck with another?”

Deputies tased him—twice—but Schultz just powered through like a meth-fueled Terminator. He then hopped into a cop car, possibly thinking, “If I can’t have the garden shears, I’ll take the shotgun!”

Spoiler: The deputies disagreed.

Sheriff Grady Judd later confirmed Schultz had a colorful criminal history (read: lots of meth). So, in the end, the gator didn’t get him—but the cops did.

Moral of the story? If you survive an alligator attack, maybe just… go home.

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

Get Our Weekly Newsletter!

Your Weekly Fix of Florida's Wildest Tales – Straight to Your Inbox!